Discussion questions

The Pleasures of Translation
Date: Thursday 18 October 2018
Time: 7:30 – 9:00 p.m.
Venue: 序言書室 Hong Kong Reader Bookstore
(7/F, 68 Sai Yeung Choi Street South, Mong Kok, Hong Kong)
{Readers’ bios}

1. How do you think translation provides you with opportunities that ordinary readers might not have?

2. What are the pleasures of finding works that you really want to translate? AND what tend to be the works you want to translate, and why?

3. Can you talk about the pleasures and challenges of collaborating with other translators?

4. Based on your own experience, what are the best things about translating a living author?

5. George Eliot once said ‘a good translator is infinitely below the man who produces good original works’. Has being a translator ever inspired some writing of your own, or informed your own writing?

6. To what extent do you agree with the statement that ‘Translation navigates between making the strange familiar and the familiar strange’? (Mark Polizzotti)

7. FOLLOW-UP: To what extent do you agree with the statement that translation can be considered as ‘a preventative against cultural atrophy and homogenisation’? (Mark Polizzotti)

8. For you, is what you are translating also your favourite text?

9. Are there any poetic works that you as a translator and maybe a cultural gatekeeper, if you will, would refuse to translate?

10. For the last question, I just want to go back to Eliot Weinberger, who inspired the theme and title of tonight’s reading. In an interview, he was asked the question, ‘What would happen if all translation ceased?’ My question is: What do you think would happen if there was no more translation in this world? (EW’s answer: We’d all be a lot dumber.)

The Pleasures of

divider 4Feminist Translators
Date: Friday 5 October 2018
Time: 7:30 – 10:30 p.m.
Venue: Swing A Cat
(Rear Shop, G/F, 241 To Kwa Wan Road, Kowloon, Hong Kong)
{Readers’ bios}

1. What does it take to be a feminist translator?

2. Why is it important to translate more female writers in the current cultural, political and globalised environment?

3. Do you actively seek out female writers to translate? Do you have much control over what writers or texts you get to translate?

4. What are a translator’s obligations and responsibilities—if any?

5. What sets feminist translators apart from other translators?

6. FOLLOW-UP: Is translating as a feminist concerned mostly with choice of texts or does it have anything to do with word choices or other linguistic characteristics?

7. Based on your own experience, what are the challenges faced by translators in general and female translators specifically?

8. The first ENG translation of Homer’s Odyssey was published in 1615 (by George Chapman), and since then, 60 English translations (half of them in the last 100 years and a dozen in the last two decades). Last year, for the first time, a new translation of Homer’s Odyssey by a female translator—Emily Wilson—was published. Why do you think it has taken so long for The Odyssey to have a female translator? And what do you think is the significance of this ‘event’ in the world of translation?

9. Xi Xi, in an interview, said the following: ‘For me, the only differences between men and women are biological. Women have been exploited, just as people have been discriminated against for the colour of their skin or the language they speak. Women are always put into a separate mould. Here we say writers, unless she’s a woman in which case she’s a “female writer”—there are no “male writers.” I think we should be beyond talking about “men (male)” and “women (female).” Is what Xi Xi said, about going beyond the distinction between male and female, helpful for you to perceive your work as a translator or poet?

10. Can you share with us ONE very memorable experience of yours as a translator?

Feminist Translatorsdivider 4Irish Voices
Date: Wednesday 3 October 2018
Time: 7:30 – 9:00 p.m.
Venue: Consulate General of Ireland/Hong Kong & Macau
(20th Floor, 33 Des Voeux Road, Central, Hong Kong)
{Readers’ bios.}

1. You are all, of course, emigrants, as many Irish people, from both north and south, are. How different do you feel as an Irish person living outside Ireland? And how do you think living abroad, or in exile if you will, has shaped your writing or other creative works?

2. Ireland has produced a large number of famed writers, such as Swift, Wilde, Joyce, Beckett, and Heaney, who have made Irish literature famous internationally. Which Irish writers inform your work, or do you try to resist their influence?

3. Stephen Daedalus, at the end of Joyce’s Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, famously said, ‘I go to encounter for the millionth time the reality of experience and to forge in the smithy of my soul the uncreated conscience of my race.’ Do you think this has set the tone for a certain type of national introspection?

4. Are there any Irish writers, whom you would like to be better known, either inside Ireland or abroad?

5. Where do you think Irish literature stands on a global scale? What other literatures, if any, do you measure it against?

6. How do you think Ireland is perceived in Asia? And in Hong Kong?CRS_Irish Voices

divider 4When you Come to the Gates of Go
Date: Wednesday 6 December 2017
Time: 7:30 – 9:00 p.m.
Venue: 序言書室 Hong Kong Reader Bookstore
(7/F, 68 Sai Yeung Choi Street South, Mong Kok, Hong Kong)
{Readers’ bios}

1. Do you feel more comfortable translating from Chinese to English OR English to Chinese? When and how did you come to this realisation?

2. What is your idea of a ‘good translation’?

3. Can you share with us some past challenges that you encountered in your history as a translator? Any particularly memorable episodes?

4. Who can be a translator? What qualities does he/she need to have?

5. Do you translate everything that comes your way? Or do you have any selection criteria?

6. What is your view on commissioned work?

7. You do literary translation. What do you think should be taught in universities in relation to translation?

Lucas Klein and Chris Song.jpgdivider 4